
Judge Milwyn Jarman KC said Ms Esteban’s assertion “has the potential to lead to impracticability, if not absurdity”.
He said: “It would mean that those entitled to use the right of way could drive a vehicle up to a point adjacent to the front door of the villa, but no further and not on to the villa. They could not park on the track for any length of time, or on the farm land.
“Assuming a right so interpreted would allow them to turn the vehicle around rather than reverse down the track, they would then have to drive off and find somewhere else to park.
“In my judgment, the claimants are entitled to a declaration that their vehicular right of way extends to the space at the north side of the villa, where they presently park their vehicles.”
Ms Esteban argued that a hedge had surrounded the villa at the time the right of way was granted, and that it would have made no sense for the right of way to entitle the owners to go any further than the gap in the hedge by the front door.
Judge Jarman rejected her argument.
Court of Appeal challenge
Ms Esteban is now challenging that ruling at the Court of Appeal in London, along with the £135,000 costs bill she was handed.
Daniel Bromilow, for Ms Esteban, told Lord Justice Miles, Lord Justice Fancourt and Lord Justice Butcher that the High Court judge “did not base his decision by construing the 1949 conveyance and the conveyance plan, but simply determined what he thought the parties should have agreed to in relation to the right of way”.
He argued against Ms Esteban being handed her neighbours’ costs bill for the case, saying she had “succeeded to a significant extent on her counterclaim”, including winning a finding that a new water pipe had been installed unlawfully on her land by the couple, as well as having “successfully resisted substantial elements” of their case.
Owen Curry, for Mr and Mrs Gould, urged the appeal judges to uphold the decision.
The judges have reserved their decision on the appeal, to be given at a later date.



